
Looe Key
Key Largo calls itself the “Dive Capital of the World”. I haven’t been able to find out why. To me, the phrase “Dive Capital of the World” would mean outstanding diving, but I don’t think that is how the tourism industry means it. When you look at the top ten reasons the tourism boards list to dive the keys, they mostly have to do with ease and convenience of diving there. You can drive there, you don’t need to enter another country, hear a foreign language, or have a passport. It is certainly easy, but is that enough to qualify it as the dive capital of the world? Not in my book. Besides, we think all the “hassle” of foreign countries is part of the fun.
There are a lot of reasons to visit the keys. The state parks are terrific, the water and weather were warm, the snorkeling was fantastic, and the lifestyle is laid-back. However, the diving is just OK. I talked to several other divers that thought it was awesome. Whenever I heard that, I would ask where they had dove before. Invariably, the answer was New Jersey, Seattle, a quarry, this is my first trip, etc. The people that thought it was awesome had never dove outside the USA. We did meet some divers that have dove in Fiji, and they thought it was just ok, too. I think it really depends on your previous diving experience. If you are a new diver, you will love it. If you have dove around the world, it will probably rank at the bottom of your list. Doesn’t mean you shouldn’t dive there, it just means you will probably find other locations better.
We weren’t going to the keys just to dive. We were going to the keys and going to do some diving while we were there. There’s a difference. It wasn’t a dive trip. It was a trip with some diving. We weren’t disappointed because we had low expectations. We couldn’t imagine it comparing to Bonaire or Curacao, and we were right, it didn’t. I did a lot of research and and kept coming across the same info. Many sites said you shouldn’t miss Looe Key in the lower keys, and you have to dive Pennekamp. I wouldn’t agree about Looe Key. I think you could easily miss it and devote most of your dives to Pennekamp. The coral in both places was damaged and dying. There is a lot more rock than coral. There are some nice patches of reef, but no awe-inspiring formations. The marine life was better than the coral. Plenty of healthy fish. However, our best dive in the keys was not as good as our worst dive in Bonaire.

We saw many Midnight Parrotfish in the keys
I am writing this in case anyone else goes looking for diver’s reviews of the keys. The dive operators will all tell you it’s terrific. The websites will say the same. It’s not. It’s easy and convenient and in the US. I would call it the Dive Capital of the US, but not the world.
After saying all that……There are very few places in the world that you can dive on coral reefs. Global warming is projected to destroy coral reefs as soon as 2050. This would be a horrible tragedy. We are grateful to have the opportunity to see them while they are still here, in any form.
If time and money are a consideration, head to the keys. If you can manage a week and a slightly larger budget, dust off your passport.